
The Salem Gazette, November 1, 1822
The Episcopal Parish of St. Paul’s Church on Essex Street bid an early fair-thee-well to seven devoted young women of the parish who are blessed and dispatched to Montreal Canada to take orders in the service of nursing the sick and spreading the word of the church to the newly formed Episcopalian St. Paul’s of Montreal.
It was a simple leave-taking in the dark and cold misty morning, no families present for the send-off of their daughters upon the pre-dawn departure. Each young woman travelled unburdened of any luggage or valise. All were dressed in black cloaks with faces shielded by heavy black veils.
The stage took off for Albany, New York immediately after the young women silently boarded. It is expected, by the haste of the four horses pulling at the reins, they will reach their expected destination far ahead of schedule.
The Salem Gazette, November 7, 1822
The town of Beverly proper and the surrounding towns are reeling in the wake of a terrible tragedy which resulted in unspeakable loss of life. The well-built and sturdy dory Nora Elizabeth, owned and masterfully manned by Captain John Russell capsized in calm seas last night. All on board perished. While facts are few, the list of confirmed dead are as follows:
Captain John Russell
The Reverend Pastor Byron Hughes
Robert and Morris Hughes, sons to Rev. Hughes and Mrs. Amelia Hughes
Mr. Charles Baker Esq., Lawyer
Mr. Asa Simpson, Banker
Mr. William Johnson, Businessman
Mr. Bertram Russell, Seaman, nephew of Captain Russell
Mr. Isaac Watson, Smithy
Mr. Maurice Merriweather, Accountant
Mr. Owen Higgins, Churchwarden
Sheriff Francis Boyle released this brief statement: “It appears the party aboard Captain John Russell’s dory were on a fishing expedition when it capsized. The boat was overloaded and it was dark. From the bloated state of the bodies that washed up in the southern corner of Fish Flake wharf, it looked like they had been in the water for over a week but the accident happened at some point around midnight. There has been no fishing tackle recovered at this time. Relatives have been interviewed and are at a complete loss as to why the men would embark on a fishing expedition in the middle of the night or what would possess them all to get into a boat that clearly could not support ten stout men.”
Diary of Virginia Southerland. (Entries of Extraordinary Interest)
27 November 1822
It has been nearly one month and I am not able to lift myself from the terror that plagues me day and night. I fear not just for my life for I believe I must be the next to die yet I believe I will lose my mind long before I take my last breath. Not only my sanity but my dear Mother’s as well. She knows! She knows it is something awful but she can never know how bad. Her wretched body suffers so from the arthritis yet her Faith and Goodness never let her sink to the despair that would devour her if she learned the truths. I can not allow her to know any of this.
Let her believe Mary is in Montreal learning to tend to the sick and spreading the Good Word of the Lord. Let her heart never know what I carry.
She tends to me with such loving care that I deserve not and can not nearly bear except that I love my Mother. My heart breaks more when she begs me to tell her what sickens me.
If only I could. It would murder her if I should.
There is little sensibility in what I write. It came to me that if I were to write it down once, I could be relieved of this wrenching burden. I would bury it after making record of that which I could never speak. I would bury the secret, the evil, the horror. That I am alive when so many are dead astounds me.
Yet I can’t bring myself to put words to this Hell. I simply can’t.
28 November 1822
I grow sicker with lack of sleep. I can foresee no other course than what I hope will release me from my haunting visions. I write this to release myself. I can not bear to see my mother’s face when she looks at me.
Those silly girls believed they were safe, that all intolerance and fear which many had suffered and died for was far in the past. Annabelle was their leader. Leave it to her to unearth what I know should have remained hidden and buried. She was always far too bold and inquisitive.
They believed they could heal and use their dark magic for good. It was prideful, they were careless.
I had been watching Mary for many days and came to know that she was stealing out of the house after dark. Finally I could stand no more and I came upon her as she prepared to creep out. she begged me to go away which frightened me. I pleaded with her to tell me what she was doing. I voiced my fear that if she must hide, it must be wrong. My distress encouraged her to bring me, to show me what they did meant no harm but Annabelle sent me away when she saw me. Her reason was their number must be Seven not Eight.
It made no sense at all and those bold young women banished me! Even Mary told me to run home. But I hid where I could watch. They removed all but their under garments. They lit a small fire, joined hands and prayed in a circle. They sang and chanted and danced around the circle. They prayed for good, for healing power, for strength to make the sick well but it was not a prayer to the Lord God Our Father and I know it was wrong. What they were saying and doing was wrong in the eyes of God and Man. When they finished, they dressed and left. I followed Mary and confronted her nearly at home. She was not shameful, she was delighted but warned me never, never tell a soul. It was Witchcraft. I nearly fainted and cried to her, how could she call the Devil himself? Mary laughed again, so carefree and told me there was no Devil in Witchcraft, only healing and good. She learned from Annabelle who found a secret book. They had been practicing rituals for nearly three months. Mary had been praying for Mother and wouldn’t you know, just three days earlier Mother said she felt a lifting of her pain? I cried but Mary would not repent. I begged her to let me come with her but she would have none of that either. She warned me not to speak one word of this until I die. Mary told me that others may have suspicions. It came to me then, the Mission to the North was made up of Annabelle, Mary, Abigail, Lucy, Betsy, Esther and Sarah. Was it Pastor Hughes’ desire to expel them for their acts? Mary laughed then scorned the idea that Pastor Hughes had any notion of their actions. Her confidence gave me strength in a hope that she was not damned. She acted as good and caring as she always had and spoke of her Mission with the highest of hopes and expectations. I could not reconcile myself to what I saw and was determined to follow her again without her knowledge. I wanted to believe she was doing no harm but when she left our home after dark on Hallows Eve, I could not help but be filled with dread. Alas, I can not write further on this now.
29 November 1822
It must be finished.
The girls formed a circle around a fire. It was so dark, a new moon night. Annabelle again bade them to undress which to my utter mortification, they did! And they danced and sang with abandon–songs in a language no longer spoken. It was not Christian. They should not have been doing what they were doing. If I had the strength to beg them to stop I would have to save their mortal souls but I didn’t. And I wanted to believe that Mary was good. It is my only wish that I had that strength for had I stopped them, I would have saved them…
The circle was burst upon by at least eight men, perhaps more. They lit torches after they overpowered the poor girls, I recognized some faces although I hardly knew them for their horrid expressions. From my refuge I could see Pastor Hughes, his two grown sons, Smithy Watson, Mr. Baker, Mr. Simpson, Captain Russell, his nephew Bertram and perhaps Mr. Johnson.
Their faces were terrible and they showed no mercy upon the poor naked young women. They bound their hands and feet and gagged their cries. They threw them over their horses and ran them through the woods and down to the waterfront at Fish Flake Hill where the old wharf barely stands. I followed them to the top of the sea wall where I could not make myself go further for the sight of what they did fills me with something worse than horror. I don’t wonder how they did not see me for these terrible men were so taken by their task at hand, I believe I could have walked among them.
Churchwarden Higgins was waiting at the bottom of the seawall, shovel in hand. He had dug seven pits in the muck as the tide was out but rising. The men stood my Mary and the others each in their own pit then Mr. Higgins shoveled the mud and sand in the holes around each of them until they were buried up to their necks.
It was then that Pastor Hughes removed their gags.
Each girl begged for her life. I can not get their cries out of my head. Mary’s haunts me the most. Nor can I escape the laughter of Pastor or the men at their heartbreaking beseeching for their lives. He condemned them to the Devil and proclaimed an Eternity of Suffering upon each of them. Death would come by the sea at the rising tide. The Devil would take their souls to Eternal Damnation.
These men of God laughed at their cries and shook hands,congratulating one and other before mounting. They agreed to meet at the tavern to discuss punishment for the families for it had gone far beyond sending wayward girls to Canada, this was the Devil’s work.
After they left, I crept onto those abominably slippery rocks. The tide was rising swiftly and I had to get Mary out. They were all crying for the Lord’s mercy begging for their lives. Before I could reach them, an unspeakably terrible dark form appeared. It was not a man for it floated over the water which was only three feet from where those poor girls were buried.
“Who begs for their life on this night?” it spoke in a voice so frightful but not loud, no more like a dark whisper in my head. Their cries for mercy became cries of dread, as did mine.
“Who would let me save them from this ghastly ordeal?” it breathed.
“No! No!” “Mercy, no!” “Not you!” “Dear Lord save us!” “No!” they screamed.
“I have been summoned,” It whispered, “I am here. Who will take my hand to save their life?”
It reached out a ghostly black palm toward their poor heads. I covered my face as I could not bear to witness this horror.
“If you will not accept me, you all will die. But I will not come in vain, I will have my prize. Who would you offer in your stead?” It said.
Shrieks of “Mercy!” Leave us!” “Save us Lord!” came from those wretched girls.
“I will lessen your suffering, you will die quickly” it whispered, “if you offer others in your place.”
“Them!” “The men!” “Those who buried us!” “Them!” “Them!” “Them!” “Them!”
“So you all decide, so it will be done.” and as It rose, a huge wave fell upon them. A wall of sea rose crashed over the seawall. The alley beyond was flooded. I held onto the cold, slippery rock for my life. The water retreated and left me cold and soaked. Silence crushed me. All that was left of my dear sister Mary, of Annabelle, Abigail, Lucy, Betsy, Esther and of Sarah were their seaweed covered heads.
The Salem Gazette, November 30, 1822
More tragedy follows too soon after the November 6th catastrophic wreck of Captain John Russell’s dory the Nora Elizabeth. Miss Virginia Southerland, beloved daughter of the Widow Leonore Southerland (m. Edward William Southerland, deceased at sea June 1818) fell to her death on the rocks at the southern wall on Fish Flake Hill. Her fall was unwitnessed but Sheriff Boyle surmises Miss Southerland must have either slipped off the rotting section of the wharf or possibly fell from the rock wall. The Sheriff has not released any information as to why the poor lass was wandering around the wharf area ash she is not connected in any way to the fishing industry nor is she acquainted with any such person who may have had reason to be there. He cautions all citizens to beware and not to trespass. The wharf has been restricted since the November 6th drowning of ten notable men.
This leave poor Widow Southerland quite on her own as her eldest daughter Mary is among the missing as a one of the seven young women of the Northern Mission of St. Paul’s to Montreal. Alms to Widow Southerland along with offerings of food and warm bedding may be left upon the poor woman’s door. All signs point to a long and cold winter for this unfortunate who will suffer without the loving care of either daughter.
The Salem Gazette, June 12, 1823
All construction has indefinitely ceased on the southern wharf at Fish Flake Hill after the fourth crew of workers quit on the spot.
“It’s ha’aunted, plain and simple!” sputtered Joseph Barnet after making the sign of the cross, “You can hear girls calling out, crying and begging. You can see their faces sometimes but when you look again, it’s rocks or posts covered with seaweed. I tell you, I will never return to that Damned place. Not after what happened to those men in the Nora Elizabeth. They shouldn’t build nothing over there. Just well enough to leave it alone.”
The Salem Gazette, September 9, 1823
St. Paul’s Episcopal Church in Montreal has confirmed the dreaded truth that the Northern Mission of young women dispatched to help the sick and spread the work of the church never arrived. Their disappearance has been a mystery. Their last known place was Albany, New York where their stage coach was to have met a second stage headed north. Augustus McKilbride, driver of the stage that left Salem on November 1st was extensively interviewed by Sherrif Boyle and Judge Horatio Nelson and was found Innocent of All Mischief. Mr. McKilbride said his horses ran like they were being whipped by the devil and the stage carried light although it was full of seven young women. They arrived in Albany in three days time, a record as far as he was aware. He noted that the entire trip was enshrouded in a cold fog and he was happy to arrive at their destination in such haste. The women disembarked from the coach at night, all dressed in black and never said a word or thanks which he felt no surprise because they never said a thing to him at any point during the trip. The last Mr. McKilbride ever saw of the seven young women was when they disembarked at the watering trough in the center of Albany. He assumed they walked on to the Albany Inn, three blocks north of the trough because it appeared they were headed in that direction. John Blake, owner of the Blake House confirms Mr. McKilbride and his horses stayed the night of November 5th.
END
Help others enjoy Sweetman's writing!